Ivanov: More outrage over song than failure to establish CSM and consequences for Serbian community
Helena Ivanov, Associate Research Fellow at the Henry Jackson Society, said that if accountability is demanded over a song, then there must also be accountability when the lives of an entire community are at stake.
Reacting to a statement by former Kosovo President Vjosa Osmani, who called for accountability after the song “Oj Kosovo, Kosovo” was performed at the opening of the EU Enlargement Forum in Brussels, as well as to reactions from the European Union, Ivanov said it would have been welcome if Pristina and Europe had shown the same level of outrage over the failure to establish the Community of Serb Municipalities (CSM).
“If only Pristina and the rest of the EU were equally outraged by Kosovo’s continued failure to establish the Community of Serb Municipalities, an obligation Kosovo itself accepted back in 2013 as part of the Brussels Agreement. The lyrics of ‘Oj Kosovo, Kosovo’ do not incite violence or promote ethnic hatred. The controversy stems from references to Kosovo as Serbian territory, and I understand why Pristina would object to that. But surely we can distinguish between the political symbolism of a song and actual political decisions that have serious consequences for people’s lives,” Ivanov wrote on the social media platform X.
She said Pristina should ask itself what political message it was sending by failing to fulfill its obligations.
“Vjosa Osmani describes the song as ‘a political message with a history.’ Fine, but I wonder what political message Pristina has been sending by failing for years to fulfill its obligations, alongside a series of unilateral measures that have made everyday life increasingly difficult for the Serbian community in Kosovo. And this is what I find particularly frustrating about the entire controversy. One song has managed to trigger enormous outrage, demands for accountability and a diplomatic dispute. Meanwhile, we have an agreement that remains unimplemented more than 13 years after it was signed, and an entire community whose daily life is affected by political decisions made in Pristina,” Ivanov added.
She called for Pristina to be held accountable for its obligations toward the Serbian community.
“I am not questioning anyone’s right to object to the song. I am questioning why we seem considerably more outraged by the symbolism of a few minutes of music than by political decisions with real consequences for people on the ground. Osmani ends her statement by asking: ‘Who chose this, who approved it, and most importantly, who takes responsibility?’ Well, I would like to ask the same questions about Pristina’s unilateral measures and its failure to implement the Community. Who made those decisions? Who approved them? And, most importantly, who takes responsibility for their consequences?” Ivanov asked.
She concluded that if accountability matters when it comes to a song, it should matter considerably more when the lives of an entire community are at stake.
The Serbian patriotic song “Oj Kosovo, Kosovo” was performed at the opening of the EU Enlargement Forum in Brussels, prompting numerous reactions in Pristina, while the European Union and the European Commission said that the performance did not reflect their views.
0 comments